Easy Orange Creamsicle Poke Cake

Introduction & Inspiration

Get ready to be transported back to childhood summers with this incredibly fun and easy Orange Creamsicle Poke Cake! If you love the classic taste of an orange creamsicle – that perfect blend of bright, sweet orange and creamy vanilla – then you’ll absolutely adore this cake. We start with a simple vanilla cake mix, enhance it with orange zest, then poke it full of holes and infuse it with a vibrant orange Jell-O mixture. The crowning glory is a light, fluffy, and uniquely fruity frosting made with mandarin oranges, vanilla pudding mix, and Cool Whip.

My inspiration for this recipe comes from wanting to capture that specific, beloved creamsicle flavor in an easy-to-make cake format. Poke cakes are brilliant for their moistness and ability to soak up flavor, making it the perfect vehicle for this orange-vanilla dream. The mandarin orange frosting is a delightful surprise!

This cake is perfect for summer parties, potlucks, kids’ birthdays, or anytime you want a cheerful, no-fuss dessert that’s bursting with nostalgic flavor. It’s sweet, creamy, fruity, and so simple to assemble! It is a perfect easy cake recipe.

Nostalgic Appeal / Comfort Factor

Orange Creamsicles are a quintessential nostalgic treat, especially associated with hot summer days, ice cream trucks, and carefree childhood moments. The combination of tangy orange and creamy vanilla is instantly recognizable and deeply comforting for many. Poke cakes, with their fun, slightly retro vibe and ultra-moist texture, also hold a special place in the comfort food hall of fame, often appearing at casual gatherings.  

This recipe beautifully marries these two nostalgic concepts. You get the familiar, beloved flavor profile of an orange creamsicle, delivered in the easy, crowd-pleasing format of a poke cake. The bright colors and sweet, creamy taste are pure happiness.

It’s a playful, sweet treat that’s guaranteed to bring smiles and evoke fond memories. A perfect comfort food dessert.

Homemade Focus (Easy Assembly with Mixes)

Let’s embrace the joy of effortless dessert creation! This Orange Creamsicle Poke Cake relies heavily on convenient, store-bought ingredients: vanilla cake mix, orange Jell-O, canned mandarin oranges, instant vanilla pudding mix, and Cool Whip. This is what makes it so wonderfully easy and accessible for everyone!

The “homemade” aspect here lies entirely in the fun assembly process – preparing the doctored cake mix, making the Jell-O soak, poking the holes (the best part!), mixing the unique mandarin orange frosting, and layering it all together. Even with these shortcuts, you’re creating a unique, flavorful dessert in your own kitchen.

This recipe is a perfect example of how cleverly combining convenient ingredients can result in a truly special and delicious homemade-tasting treat with minimal effort. The perfect balance between easy and delicious.

Flavor Goal

The primary flavor goal is to perfectly capture the essence of an Orange Creamsicle: a harmonious blend of bright orange and creamy vanilla flavors. The vanilla cake base, enhanced with orange zest and infused with orange Jell-O, should be incredibly moist and carry both vanilla and orange notes.

The orange Jell-O soak should add intense orange flavor and a fun, jiggly texture within the cake. The unique mandarin orange frosting, made with undrained mandarins and vanilla pudding mix blended with Cool Whip, should be light, fluffy, creamy, and bursting with sweet citrusy-orange flavor.

The overall experience should be a cool, creamy, very moist cake that tastes undeniably like an Orange Creamsicle – sweet, fruity, with a lovely vanilla creaminess. A perfect combination of flavour and texture.

Ingredient Insights

For the Cake:

• Vanilla Cake Mix (+ ingredients on box): The convenient base. Prepare according to package (eggs, oil, water/milk). White or yellow cake mix works.
• Orange Zest: Added to the cake mix for a fresh, aromatic orange note.
• Orange JELL-O (Dry Mix): Provides intense orange flavor and color that soaks into the cake. Use one standard 3.4 oz box.
• Boiling Water: Essential for properly dissolving the Jell-O powder.
• Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice: Added to the Jell-O mixture for a brighter, more authentic orange flavor than Jell-O alone.

For the Mandarin Orange Frosting:

• Canned Mandarin Oranges (Undrained): The key to this unique frosting! Using the undrained fruit with its light syrup provides moisture and mandarin flavor. A standard 15 oz can.
• Vanilla Instant Pudding Mix (Dry Mix): Acts as a thickener and stabilizer for the frosting when combined with the mandarins and Cool Whip, while also adding vanilla flavor. Must be instant. (3.5 oz box).
• Cool Whip (Frozen Whipped Topping, Thawed): Provides the light, fluffy, stable base for the frosting. Ensure it’s fully thawed.

Essential Equipment

• 9×13 Inch Baking Pan: Standard size for baking the cake mix and assembling the dessert. Needs to be greased/floured.
• Large Bowl & Mixer (Optional): For preparing cake mix batter per box instructions.
• Heatproof Bowl: For dissolving Jell-O.
• Whisk: For Jell-O and frosting.
• Skewer or Handle of a Wooden Spoon: For poking holes in the cooled cake.
• Medium Bowl: For making the mandarin orange frosting.
• Electric Mixer (Handheld): Recommended for beating the mandarin orange frosting ingredients together.
• Spatula: For spreading pudding soak and frosting.
• Measuring Cups & Spoons:
• Microwave (Optional, for frosting): Recipe mentions warming canned strawberry frosting in previous user recipe, but this recipe’s frosting is no-cook. I’ll omit microwave for frosting here.
• Plastic Wrap or Lid: For covering cake during chilling.

Ingredients

(Based on 1x column)

Cake:

• ▢ 1 box (15.25 ounces) vanilla cake mix, plus ingredients listed on packaging (e.g., eggs, oil, water/milk)
• ▢ 1 tablespoon orange zest

Orange Jell-O Soak:

• ▢ 1 package (3.4 ounces) orange JELL-O mix
• ▢ 1 ¼ cup boiling water
• ▢ ⅓ cup fresh squeezed orange juice

Mandarin Orange Frosting:

• ▢ 1 can (15 ounces) mandarin oranges, undrained
• ▢ 1 package (3.5 ounces) vanilla instant pudding mix (dry)
• ▢ 8 ounces frozen whipped topping (1 standard tub), thawed

Optional Garnish:

• ▢ Fresh orange slices or extra mandarin segments

Step-by-Step Instructions

1. Prepare and Bake the Cake:

• Preheat your oven according to the temperature specified on the vanilla cake mix box.
• Grease and flour a 9×13-inch baking pan.
• Prepare the cake batter according to the package instructions, using the ingredients (eggs, oil, water/milk – recipe suggests substituting milk/vanilla almondmilk for water) listed on the box. Stir the 1 tablespoon of orange zest into the prepared batter.
• Pour the batter into the greased and floured 9×13 inch pan and spread evenly.
• Bake according to the package directions, or until a toothpick inserted into the center comes out clean.
• Remove the cake from the oven and let it cool on a wire rack for approximately 10 minutes. Then, let it continue to cool completely in the pan (or remove to rack if preferred, but it’s often easier to poke/fill in the pan).  

2. Prepare Jell-O Soak and Poke Cake:

• Once the cake has cooled significantly (can still be slightly warm, but not hot), use a skewer or the round handle of a thin wooden spoon to poke rows of holes all over the top surface of the cake, about an inch apart.
• In a medium heatproof bowl, add the orange JELL-O mix powder. Carefully pour the 1 ¼ cup of boiling water over the JELL-O. Whisk until the JELL-O powder has completely dissolved.
• Stir in the ⅓ cup of fresh squeezed orange juice.
• Carefully and slowly pour this warm JELL-O mixture evenly over the top of the poked cake, trying to get it into all the holes.

3. Chill the Cake (Jell-O Layer):

• Cover the pan with plastic wrap.
• Refrigerate the cake for at least 3 hours, or preferably longer (even overnight), to allow the JELL-O to fully set and soak into the cake, making it incredibly moist.

4. Make the Mandarin Orange Frosting:

• Ensure the frozen whipped topping is fully thawed in the refrigerator.
• In a medium bowl, combine the entire can of undrained mandarin oranges (fruit and syrup) with the dry vanilla instant pudding mix.
• Beat with an electric hand mixer (or whisk vigorously) until the oranges break down slightly and the mixture is combined and starts to thicken. It might look a bit unusual at first.
• Gently fold the thawed whipped topping into the mandarin-pudding mixture using a rubber spatula until evenly incorporated and the frosting is light and fluffy.

5. Frost the Cake:

• Remove the chilled, Jell-O soaked cake from the refrigerator.
• Spread the prepared mandarin orange frosting evenly over the top of the cake.

6. Final Chill and Serve:

• Refrigerate the frosted cake for at least another 30 minutes to allow the frosting to set and chill properly.
• Slice the Orange Creamsicle Poke Cake into squares directly from the pan.
• Serve chilled. Garnish with fresh orange slices or extra mandarin segments if desired. Enjoy!

Troubleshooting

• Cake Dry: Overbaked initial cake layer. The Jell-O soak adds significant moisture, so this is less common.
• Jell-O Didn’t Soak In/Set: Holes too small, cake too hot when Jell-O poured, Jell-O not fully dissolved, or insufficient chilling time. Ensure cake is mostly cool, holes are adequate, Jell-O fully dissolved, and chill thoroughly.
• Frosting Too Runny: Whipped topping was too warm/watery, or instant pudding mix didn’t activate properly with mandarin liquid. Ensure Cool Whip is thawed but cold. Ensure using instant pudding. The frosting should be soft and fluffy but hold its shape. Chill helps it set.
• Frosting Lumpy: Instant pudding mix didn’t fully dissolve or was clumpy. Whisk/beat well.
• Layers Separating/Messy Slicing: Cake not chilled long enough for all layers to fully set and meld. Chilling is key for poke cakes.

Tips and Variations

• Cool Cake Adequately: Before poking and adding Jell-O, let cake cool at least 30-60 minutes. Before frosting, ensure Jell-O layer is set.
• Poking Technique: Use wooden spoon handle for larger holes. Space them evenly.
• Instant Pudding/Jell-O: Ensure they are “instant” and “gelatin dessert” respectively, not cook-and-serve types.
• Orange Cake Mix: For even more orange flavor, use an orange cake mix as the base instead of vanilla/white.
• Vanilla Frosting Option: If preferred, use a standard vanilla buttercream or cream cheese frosting instead of the mandarin orange frosting.
• Add Orange Extract: A 1/2 teaspoon of orange extract to the cake batter or frosting can boost the orange flavor.
• Garnish Creatively: Top with orange zest, orange-themed sprinkles, or small dollops of plain whipped cream before adding mandarin slices.

Serving and Pairing Suggestions

• Serve Chilled: This cake is best served cold, straight from the refrigerator.
• Potlucks & Parties: The 9×13 format makes it perfect for sharing at gatherings.
• Summer Dessert: Light, fruity, and refreshing.
• With Iced Tea or Lemonade: Perfect beverage pairings.

Nutritional Information

(Note: Estimated, per serving, assuming 12-15 servings from a 9×13 pan. Very sweet dessert, highly variable based on specific brands of mixes, topping, syrup.)

• Calories: 350-480+
• Fat: 15-25g+
• Saturated Fat: 6-12g+
• Cholesterol: 25-50mg+ (depending on cake mix ingredients)
• Sodium: 350-500mg+ (Mixes/Jell-O can be high)
• Total Carbohydrates: 50-70g+
• Dietary Fiber: <1-2g
• Sugars: 35-50g+ (Very sweet)
• Protein: 3-5g+

Print

Recipe Summary and Q&A

Summary: This Easy Orange Creamsicle Poke Cake starts with a vanilla cake mix baked in a 9×13 pan, enhanced with orange zest. After cooling and poking holes, a mixture of dissolved orange Jell-O and fresh orange juice is poured over to soak in. Once chilled and set, the cake is topped with a unique, fluffy frosting made by beating undrained canned mandarin oranges with dry vanilla instant pudding mix and then folding in thawed frozen whipped topping. The cake is chilled again before slicing and serving.  

Q&A:

• Q: Does the cake mix need its box ingredients (eggs, oil, water)?
  • A: Yes! The recipe states “white cake mix + ingredients list on packaging.” You prepare the cake mix as directed on its box, adding the orange zest to that batter. The milk/almondmilk mentioned in the original text for the cake was a substitution for water, which is fine.
• Q: Why use undrained mandarin oranges and dry pudding mix for the frosting?
  • A: This is a clever shortcut! The liquid from the undrained mandarin oranges provides the necessary moisture to activate the dry instant pudding mix, which then helps to thicken and stabilize the Cool Whip, all while infusing it with mandarin orange flavor. It creates a unique, light, fruity frosting.
• Q: Can I use fresh mandarin oranges for the frosting?
  • A: Canned undrained mandarins are specifically called for because the syrup they are packed in provides crucial liquid and sweetness for the pudding mix to work correctly. Fresh mandarins would not provide this same liquid/syrup and would need to be pureed and potentially have liquid/sweetener adjusted. Stick to canned for this frosting method.
• Q: How long does this cake really need to chill?
  • A: It needs at least 3 hours for the Jell-O layer to set properly within the cake. Then, after frosting, another 30 minutes to an hour for the frosting to chill and set is ideal. Overnight chilling is often best for poke cakes for flavors to meld and cake to fully moisten.